Moroccan Minister of Endowments and Islamic Affairs Meets with Undersecretary of Saudi Ministry of Islamic Affairs    Saudi Ambassador to The Philippines Meets with Filipino Minister for National Commission on Muslim Filipinos    Al-Shagdali Meets Secretary-General of Red Sea Investors Association    Weather Forecast for Friday    HRH Crown Prince Crowns Winner Al-Fayhaa with the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques' Cup 2021/2022    Jeddah Season 2022 Launches Japanese "Anime Village" with Largest Cosplay Parade    Taif Rose Festival Attracts Nearly 1 Million Visitors, Concludes with Great Success    Saudi Arabia Heads to Cannes International Film Festival to Promote Country's Flourishing Industry and Support Emerging Talent on World Stage    King, Crown Prince congratulate President Paul Biya on Cameroon's National Day    Saudi Arabia delivers humanitarian aid worth $3.2 million to Philippines    Capital Economics expects Saudi economy to grow 10% in 2022    ZATCA clarifies conditions for buying and bringing cars from abroad    Sri Lanka defaults on debt for first time in its history    Global economic growth downgraded due to spillover from Ukraine war    Saudi Arabia took important steps to enhance food security, says minister    Nations must act together to end crisis of food insecurity: UN chief    India seeks to win public trust in crisis-hit Sri Lanka    Russian soldier pleads guilty in first war crimes trial of Ukraine conflict    Three Professors Win 2022 IsDB Prize for Impactful Achievement in Islamic Economics    Saudi Arabia bags two gold medals at GCC Games    Salman bin Ibrahim to seek third term at AFC helm    US Soccer equalizes pay in milestone with women, men    Prince Khalid, Austin review Saudi-US defense ties    Hospital admissions for eating disorders soar in Britain    Saudis in Cannes: Promoting country's flourishing film industry    Saudi Stock Exchange Main Index Ends Trading Lower at 12,427.96 Points    Japan Posts Trade Deficit of 839.2 Billion Yen in April    Asian Shares Fall    Prince Faisal, Lamamra review historical ties; discuss enhancing joint cooperation    Saudi Tourism Authority Signs Over 90 Agreements and MoU in Dubai ATM 2022    President of SAFF Participates in AFC General Assembly Meeting    36 films compete for 12 awards at Saudi Film Festival    Senegalese show support to Idrissa Gueye after homophobia accusations    Saudi Athletes Achieve Great Victories in the 2nd Day of the GCC Games Tournament in Kuwait    Kay Mellor: Actress and Fat Friends creator dies aged 71    Jazan Hosts West Asian Beach Soccer Championship    Over 250 Saudi Female and Male Players to Participate in Kuwait 3rd GCC Games on Friday    Bollywood actor's tweet reignited debate over Hindi as India's national language    SFDA Advises to Wash Dates Well Before Eating    SFDA Advises Against Mixing Surplus of Iftar and Suhoor with Different Foods or Surplus from Other Days    Ministry calls on imams to avoid long supplications in Tahajjud Prayer    Nothing wrong with a Muslim celebrating birthdays, says Saudi scholar    Ranbir Kapoor and Alia Bhatt: Bollywood wishes for star couple on wedding    SFDA Warns Against Microbes Accumulation on Coffee when Stored Incorrectly    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques addresses citizens and all Muslims on the occasion of the Holy month of Ramadan    Pilgrims Perform Dhuhr and Asr Prayers at Arafat Holy Site    Council of Senior Scholars: Muslim Brothers' Group Don't Represent Method of Islam, rather only Follows its Partisan Objectives, Violating our Graceful Religion    Eid Al-Adha Prayer Performed at the Grand Holy Mosque    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Trump's potential liability for Capitol riot faces major test in court
Published in The Saudi Gazette on 11 - 01 - 2022

A federal judge in Washington, DC, is considering for the first time whether former President Donald Trump is immune from liability related to his supporters attacking the US Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021.
The major hearing on Monday is part of a trio of insurrection-related lawsuits seeking to hold Trump and others accountable at a time when the House select committee probing Jan. 6 has aggressively investigated the political leaders who inspired the attack, and as the Justice Department is prosecuting more than 700 rioters for criminal offenses.
Judge Amit Mehta of the DC District Court is looking at key questions including whether Trump and Republican figures like Rep. Mo Brooks of Alabama can shield themselves from legal fallout because of the First Amendment or their stature as elected officials.
It is the first major test of whether civil litigation is a viable route to holding Trump accountable for the violence toward Congress, after he was acquitted by the Senate in his second impeachment trial last February.
A lawyer for Trump, Jesse Binnall, argued that everything Trump said while president — including on Jan. 6 as well as in a call to Georgia officials asking them to "find" votes in early 2021 and at campaign rallies — is protected from any lawsuits, because it was all part of his official actions as president.
"You would have me ignore what [Trump] said in its entirety?" Mehta asked minutes into the hearing. The judge pointed to a Supreme Court case related to the Johnson and Nixon administrations that established the parameters of presidential immunity.
"To say that a speech before Congress is the equivalent to a campaign trail stump speech" doesn't appear to be what the Supreme Court had ruled on the boundaries of presidential immunity, Mehta said.
Democratic Rep. Eric Swalwell of California, 10 other House Democrats, and Capitol Police officers James Blassingame and Sidney Hemby brought the three lawsuits at issue on Monday.
The lawmakers say they were threatened by Trump and others as part of a conspiracy to stop the congressional session that would certify the 2020 presidential election on Jan. 6, according to the complaints. And they argue that Trump should bear responsibility for directing the assaults.
Swalwell, who described his position in the case in an interview on CNN on Sunday, said he expects Monday's hearing to be long. He noted, however, that he and others would not be permitted into the courtroom because of the recent surge in COVID-19 cases. Instead, the participants will speak to the judge over videoconference.
If the judge rules in favor of Swalwell and others who have sued, the California Democrat said he expects "it's going to speed up, and hopefully we'll move to more depositions and evidence discovery very soon."
The police officers, in their lawsuit, say they were hit by chemical sprays and objects the crowd threw at them, like water bottles and signs, because Trump inspired the crowd.
"Defendant's followers, already primed by his months of inflammatory rhetoric, were spurred to direct action," the lawsuit from Blassingame and Hemby said. "Had Trump committed directly the conduct committed by his followers, it would have subjected Trump to direct liability."
Six additional lawsuits against Trump and others for their roles in the insurrection are also in front of the same court, but haven't reached the point of being argued yet.
In the three cases before Mehta on Monday, the defendants include Trump, Brooks, Donald Trump Jr., Rudy Giuliani and right-wing groups the Proud Boys and the Oath Keepers.
In court, they are distancing themselves from the actions of the crowd on Jan. 6, and asking Mehta to dismiss the cases. According to Trump's arguments, allowing the lawsuits to go forward would "drastically" chill political speech and prompt dozens of lawsuits aimed at damaging electoral opponents.
Trump and his top advisers haven't been charged with any crimes. Several leaders in the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers who have been criminally charged with conspiracy have pleaded not guilty.
The Justice Department will be at the hearing to discuss its views toward the cases, in an important barometer of Attorney General Merrick Garland's legal approach to the insurrection.
So far, the DOJ said it will not defend Brooks' actions. According to a court filing this summer, the Justice Department argued that encouraging an attack, if proven in court, could not be considered part of Brooks' job as a public official, and the Trump rally was clearly a campaign event and not part of Brooks' official duties as a lawmaker.
But Mehta hasn't decided yet how much protection Brooks could have as a member of Congress.
The Alabama Republican is representing himself in the case brought by Swalwell — while lawyers represent all the other parties —- and is expected to argue on his own behalf on Monday.
Trump, for his part, has argued in court he has absolute immunity for his actions while president, another claim Mehta will consider.
The Democratic representatives' cases specifically focus on the language Trump, Brooks and others used at the "Stop the Steal" rally on the Ellipse in Washington, DC, directly before the attack.
Trump told the crowd to "show strength" and "walk down Pennsylvania Avenue," for instance, while Brooks, in his speech, said, "Today is the day American patriots start taking down names and kicking ass." Also at the rally, Giuliani told the crowd to have "trial by combat."
Following the speeches, hundreds of pro-Trump rally-goers marched to the Capitol, severely beating law enforcement officers guarding the building and breaking through barricades and windows to get inside.
Many then ransacked congressional offices and some chanted "treason" as they overtook the Senate chamber, from which lawmakers and then-Vice President Mike Pence had been evacuated minutes before.
"The president has been very clear he was there at the Ellipse as president," Binnall said in court Friday "He was advocating for Congress to take or not take certain actions. ... We are dead center on immunity."
After the Senate voted not to convict Trump last February, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell pointed to lawsuits as an avenue for retribution.
The Kentucky Republican said Trump was "still liable for everything he did while he was in office" and noted "we have civil litigation" from which a president would not be immune. The lawsuits could take months or even years to see resolutions. — CNN


Clic here to read the story from its source.