Iraqi President Meets with Commander of United States Central Command    UAE Deputy Prime Minister Meets with Speaker of Shura Council    Pakistani Minister of Petroleum: HRH Crown Prince's Visit Will Contribute to Enhancing Relations between the Two Countries    SAMI and Naval Group sign strategic agreement to create JV in naval defense    Israeli forces arrest 16 Palestinians in West Bank    Israeli settlers storm Al-Aqsa Mosque    KSrelief Center Continues to implement job projects in Aden governorate    HRH Crown Prince Congratulates Gambia's President on Independence Day    Austrian chancellor visits Hiroshima    Saudi Al-Ahli, Emirates Al-Wasl Drew 2-2, in Zayed Cup for Arab Clubs' Champions QF    Silver, Bronze Medals for Saudi Arabia, in the World Games for people with Disabilities, Amputation, in Sharjah    SAUDIA to Launch Direct Flights to Athens    Bahrain Bourse falls    2 million tons of cargos handled at Dhiba port during 2018    Saudi Professional League to Co-sign Sponsorship Contract with Int'l Firm, for the Next Season    Saudi Football Association Not to Renew Contract of Manager Juan Antonio Pizzi    Second Conference on Radiology Advanced Application concludes in Riyadh    Fifty films to be screened in Riyadh on Sunday as part of Salam contest for short films for civilizational communication    Saudi Novelist Wins Naguib Mahfouz Medal for Literature    Three talented females represent KSA in a forum for those with special abilities    Ministry of Hajj and Umrah Launches Awareness Message on Sacrifice Day    Who targeted Holy Kaaba?    Custodian of Two Holy Mosques addresses the Saudi people and Islamic nation on the blessed Eid Al-Fitr    Mufti of Mount Lebanon: Saudi Arabia is Heart of Islamic World and Attempts to become Audacious Against it affects Feelings of Millions Muslims    Newcastle Beat West Ham 3-0 for their first Win of the Season    Mourinho insists Ibrahimovic must be good enough for Manchester United    Reforms have saved the economy from possible recession, say analysts    The King and Crown Prince congratulates Moldova's President    More than 1,5 million pilgrims arrive in Saudi Arabia, so far    MWL allocates SR 7 million for Eid sacrifice project in 47 countries    Saudi Campaign provides educational and training services for Syrians in Al-Za'tari camp    Saudi student goes missing in Kentucky, US    Harvey lashes Texas US coast with high wind, torrential rain    North Korea tests short-range missiles as South Korea, US conduct drills    Samsung leader Jay Y. Lee given five-year jail sentence for bribery    Known days    "MODON" Signs MoU with Chinese Goldwind Company for wind-turbines manufacturing in the Kingdom    Flyadeal, Saudi Arabia's new low-cost airline, scheduled to launch on September 23, reports    Joker, Harley Quinn movie in works with 'Crazy Stupid Love' filmmakers    Mastercard launches Masterpass in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia    Honda among 27 Japan players named for World Cup qualifiers    Madhuri Dixit to venture into Marathi films as a producer    Consumers warned against using some brands of face powder, hair products    How 'GOT' makers made the frozen lake in 'Beyond the Wall'    Shraddha Kapoor wants people to help the needy    Neymar targets improvement after phenomenal home debut    Politicizing the pilgrimage    Rakhi 2017: "Bond of Love" between a brother and his sister    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.





Dilemma of teaching English in the Kingdom
Dr. Ali Mohammad Al-Asmari & M Shamsur Rabb Khan

Mofreh, member of the Shoura Council's Education Committee, and other, in response, from Abdullah Al-Muqbil, the former secretary general of the higher committee for education policy at the Ministry of Education – on teaching English at primary level might be more confusing than surprise for many. While Al-Mofreh sees teaching of English at primary level a waste of money and human resources, Al-Muqbil advocates for greater motivation to schools and teachers, in addition to revising the curriculum to improve the performance of English teachers. Rather English is to be taught, as Al-Mofreh envisions it, intensively at high school where it can be compensated. However, he cites an unattractive learning environment, less time for English teaching and lack of specialist English teachers as the reasons for poor performance of elementary and intermediate students. In response, Al-Muqbil strongly supports the same yardstick for other subjects since no one can say that teaching other subjects is a waste of time.
The arguments of both sides have opened up an academic debate on teaching of English at primary level in the Kingdom. Al-Muqbil's views seem more pragmatic in the sense that not only it will help create jobs for Saudi youths, and which will be an addition in the ongoing Saudization program, but also prepare the Saudi students for taking subject like science, computer, and engineering at university level.
One big question as to how English can be compensated at high school level where both teachers and students have to start from ABC is a difficult question. And where and how can the school find more classes for English to teach them intensively? The problem is not that schools will start devoting more time and classes for English learner at high school level, but giving less time and classes at elementary level.
Al-Mofreh's comparison of achievement level when he sees “no big difference between students at public schools and private school students who study English at a very early stage” is entirely based on personal experience, not on research studies and real time scenario prevalent in countries where English is taught as second language. As teachers, when we compare our students in the college with those of private schools at high level, we find the latter more proficient and responsive. And a large number of Saudi students at the college level often complain of lack of good teachers at the high school level. Equally, a great number of expatriate teachers at university level find it difficult to create a fitting teaching strategy when they compare the curricula to the students' proficiency level. How can, if we go by Al-Mofreh's opinion of teaching English intensively at high school, compensate it when teachers are not qualified, trained and motivated? Al-Muqbil provides half of the answer: he asks for employing female teachers at the elementary level, as is the norm in India, China, and Pakistan, for better results. The other half answer is to create qualified and trained teachers for elementary as well as high school levels, in addition to motivating them for teaching English with equal enthusiasm and attention.
We see high interest among college-going Saudi students for learning English, and the number of students enrolled for English programs, for example, in King Khalid University is much higher than that in other subjects. What the students lack is general proficiency in English that they must have acquired at the high school level where they met with lack of a stimulating environment that could help enhance their motivation level. The same is the story at elementary level. Now when university teachers try to teach them “everything” that have not been taught at both elementary and high school levels, they face even a bigger problem. Many a new university teachers try to speak English fast, using vocabulary unfamiliar to students due to which required level of learning that is supposed to be accomplished is unfortunately not done. As a result, the students who even passed out BA lack the required proficiency and expertise level in English, and these are the same students, who are employed to teach students at high school level who possess the least proficiency and motivation level.
What we experience among students in classes at university level includes: they have short attention spans; they are easily distracted from tasks; they are less responsive; they show no interest and willingness for self-paced learning; and they are always dependent on teachers' assistance for completion of tasks. There emerges a clear mismatch between the interest and enthusiasm that new students who get enrolled to learn English program carry when they enter the university premises and the shrinking interest and enthusiasm that they exhibit after a few months of learning. Barring a few exceptions, a great majority of Saudi students at college or university level happen to learn via only one evaluation test, i.e., achievement test out of four fundamental tests. The rest three, ie, proficiency test, diagnostic test and placement test, they learn when they either opt for TOEFL, or going for a job. Teachers, both at high school level and college or university level, carry the onus of creating unfriendly learning envrionment
Employment of trained female English teachers at elementary level and appointment, training and evaluation of both male and female English teachers at high school level are the prerequisites for better results. An environment of competition can be inculcated through employing a few expatriate teachers at elementary and high school levels in all schools as well. Finally, Saudi students at elementary and high school levels need to be exposed to learners of English as a second language from sub-continent through education exchange programs.
The authors are vice-dean and assistant professor, respectively, at the College of Science and Arts, Muhayel, King Khalid University, Abha. __


Clic here to read the story from its source.