Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques Congratulates President of Federal Republic of Germany on Unity Day    Saudi Arabia to Host 25th World Petroleum Congress in 2026    Tadawul All Share Index Decreases by 0.79%, Equity Market Capitalization Reaches SAR 10,832.85 Billion at End of 1st Nine Months 2022    Asian Shares Mostly Lower    Weather Forecast for Monday    KSrelief Concludes the 11th, 12th Volunteer Program in Zaatari Camp for Syrian Refugees in Jordan    Saudi Arabia, UK explore increased trade, investment opportunities Keaveny arrives in Riyadh in first visit as Lord Mayor of London    King Salman receives written message from Azerbaijan president    Prince Abdulaziz Al-Faisal to Head Saudi Delegation to Olympic Council of Asia Meetings in Cambodia    Recycling by 2035 will contribute to an annual income of SR120 billion    18 new benefit added to health insurance policy    Dr. Khalid Al-Sabti, a techy savvy leader, taking ETEC to new heights KAUST workshop on 'Basics of AI' begins at ETEC    Global philosophers to discuss science and philosophy in 2nd Riyadh Conference in December    King, Crown Prince congratulate Guinea president on Independence Day    Jail, fine for citizens involved in forging official documents of a Saudi embassy    Al-Manea: Selling gold in installments is not permissible    Saudi Stock Exchange Main Index Ends Trading Higher at 11,487 Points    MAWANI, Tabadul Sign MoU to Develop New Saudi Ports Management Systems    Saudi Arabia to Host 14th General Assembly Meeting of ARABOSAI    174 dead in Indonesian football stadium crush    Brazil polarized as Bolsonaro seeks re-election and Lula aims for comeback    Vehicle Overturn Kills 26, Injures 10 in India    At Least 127 People Killed, 180 Injured at Football Match in Indonesia    King Charles will not attend COP27, says Palace    Morocco's King congratulates Mohammed bin Salman on becoming Saudi PM    UN chief condemns any attempt to seize power by the force of arms    Saudi Arabia gets four memberships in IOC commissions    Al-Khuwaitm turns in golden display in Girls Gymnastics Championship in Riyadh    15 cups of Saudi coffee in a day are enough!    Riyadh hosts first Saudi Games on Oct. 27    19 women, 2 men qualify as Kingdom's first yogasana referees    Movies return to Kashmir with Hrithik Roshan-starrer    Body of famed US climber found on Mt Manaslu in Himalayas    Yoga introduced to Saudi universities    Islamic Minister Al-Sheikh: Juristic judgment catalyst to salvage Islamic Ummah    Culinary Arts Commission Registers 13 Foods on Slow Food List of Endangered Food    72% of Children Globally have been Victims of Cyber Threats    Saudi National Football Team Continues Preparations for Friendly Match against Ecuador    Saudi Futsal Team Beats San Marino, Wins Silver in Croatian International Championship    During 2nd Global AI Summit.. AI-powered Early Breast Cancer Detection Program Launched    Triple talaq: India Muslim women in limbo after instant divorce ruling    Film Commission Reviews Film Industry Prospects in Saudi Arabia at Venice International Film Festival    Saudi national volleyball team loses to Kyrgyzstan in Asian Challenge Cup final    Saudi national volleyball team beats Uzbekistan, qualifies for the final of the Asian Challenge Cup    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques Delivers Speech to Pilgrims, Citizens, Residents and Muslims around the World    Sheikh Al-Issa in Arafah's Sermon: Allaah Blessed You by Making It Easy for You to Carry out This Obligation. Thus, Ensure Following the Guidance of Your Prophet    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques addresses citizens and all Muslims on the occasion of the Holy month of Ramadan    Pilgrims Perform Dhuhr and Asr Prayers at Arafat Holy Site    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Flaw in the flawless
Published in The Saudi Gazette on 15 - 11 - 2013


Dr. N. Janardhan


A few months ago, I heard a conversation on the radio about Sachin Tendulkar. One cricket enthusiast asked another if it was true that the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) had put Tendulkar on retirement notice. The friend mockingly replied: “With the kind of form he has been in over the last few years, thank God, someone has taken ‘notice' of him!”
Such a joke may not be an appropriate way to honor a legend who quits competitive cricket in a few days, after scoring 100 international hundreds, playing 200 Tests and accumulating 50,000 runs across all formats, apart from scores of other records during an international career spanning 24 years – many that may remain unbroken.
Tendulkar's greater virtue has been his performance off the field. As much as the public made him a larger than life figure, his real life conduct has remained ‘almost' impeccable, unlike many other ‘fallen' sports heroes.
But, amid the rightfully-earned admiration and outpouring of superlative-laden farewell eulogies to one the greatest cricketers ever, here is an alternative perspective — without questioning the performance of Tendulkar, the individual cricketer.
Instead, the focus is, first, on the impact of his contribution on Team India's performance, vis-a-vis other ‘greats' who donned the India cap during Tendulkar's reign; and second, if Tendulkar, the player, detrimentally grew to become bigger than the sport.
Like every hero has a tragic ‘flaw', so is the case with an otherwise ‘flawless' Tendulkar.
On the first point, the grouse against Tendulkar is not because he is the greatest cricketer of this era, which is hard to contradict, but his individual contribution to the team's victories pales in comparison to the individual and collective performances of Rahul Dravid, Anil Kumble, V.V.S. Laxman, Virender Sehwag and Sourav Ganguly (who first turned things around for India as an aggressive captain, followed by the unorthodox and ‘street smart' captain, M.S. Dhoni, thereafter).
If not for any of these or all of them, India — even with Tendulkar — would not have been as successful as it has been, much like the ‘losing' Indian Test team with Sunil Gavaskar and Kapil Dev in the 1970s and 1980s.
Tendulkar was a defining cricketer in terms of individual class, style, impact on Indian cricket in general, longevity, etc., but he was not a defining individual contributor to the Indian team's success, definitely not in the same league as any one of the above-mentioned ‘Fab Five'. There are ample statistics and analyses to support this.
The question this raises is: Is cricket just entertainment? Given the amount of time, money and emotion that enthusiasts invest in following the game, it is fair to judge that it is much more. But many of us are guilty of treating it as mere entertainment, heaping praise on the ‘great entertainer', and forgetting the unsung heroes who have really done India proud.
A part of the blame for relegating the other greats to the status of ‘backroom boys' rests with the Mumbai commentary ‘mafia' — comprising Sunil Gavaskar, Sanjay Manjrekar, Ravi Shastri and Harsha Bhogle — which has reduced a team game to a one-man show.
How else can we explain the comparatively diminished buzz surrounding Dravid's impact on India's performance? If we combine his 24,000-plus runs and 400-plus catches in Test and One-Day formats, he obviously had an equally great, if not greater, impact. Ditto with Kumble's nearly 1,000 wickets in both formats; same is the case with Laxman's innumerable rearguard rescue missions batting at No. 6; and, again with Virender Sehwag's blistering starts, which helped India fairly consistently score 300-plus runs in one day of a Test match, after years of sub-250s, thus setting the stage for a definite and, more often than not, positive result for India.
On the second point of focus in this alternative perspective — yes, there was no other way for Tendulkar to fade out, except to announce his retirement himself, and rightly so. But the fact that he did it at least two years too late was unjust for him, unfair for cricket lovers, and unwarranted for the game.
When a player of Tendulkar's caliber, who did not have to prove his worth during his peak, began to get his fans tense about his tentativeness and took nearly two years to move from his 99th to 100th ton, the ‘champion' should have known it was time to gracefully leave the stage on his own for the sake of his team.
That took a bit of sheen off his otherwise glorious individual career. It has now again been 17 months since he scored a century and nearly three years since he got a Test ton!
By prolonging his career, Tendulkar has had a damaging impact on a few rising cricketing guns in much the same way as Kapil Dev's pursuit of 432 wickets had on Javagal Srinath losing out on at least two years of his good bowling years in the early 1990s.
Compare this with the selfless timing of Dravid's retirement and the rationale for it — to enable his successor (Cheteshwar Pujara) to ease into his role on home turf before heading for a tough overseas tour.
Also, consider the unceremonious way in which Laxman's retirement panned out with the BCCI reportedly telling him that the series against Australia in India would be his last and that he would be picked only if he agreed to treat it as a farewell series. Laxman eventually quit rather than yield to such insults.
On the other hand, every time Tendulkar's retirement issue was broached, he and his innumerable fans – even the selectors – claimed that it was Tendulkar's prerogative to make the final call. So much for cricket being a team sport!
To add insult to injury, the Indian cricket board went against all odds to brew a storm with its South African counterpart, by delaying the tour, and cooking up a series with the West Indies team to ensure that Tendulkar's farewell match took place in India, and that too at his ‘home' Wankhede Stadium because this was the only way his mother could view the match live! It was also meant to be a ‘risk-free' farewell as opposed to the more ‘hostile', ‘risky' and, probably, ‘non-memorable' farewell series in South Africa.
All these suggest that while Tendulkar's individual achievement is worth celebrating, cricket — a team game — was lost in translation.
However, even after this critical assessment, when the No. 4 Indian batsman walks out for the first Test against South Africa during the 2013-2014 series, all cricket enthusiasts, including me, will miss Tendulkar – not ‘the greatest', but – ‘one of the greatest' cricketers and human-heroes that the game has produced.

— A sports aficionado, Dr. N. Janardhan is a political and international affairs analyst based in the UAE.


Clic here to read the story from its source.