Saudi Arabia bags two gold medals, 2 silvers in GCC Games    Saudi Athletes Achieve Great Victories in the 2nd Day of the GCC Games Tournament in Kuwait    Director of Islamic Affairs of Al-Madinah Branch Receives General Mufti of Kosovo    Saudi Arabia Strongly Condemns Terrorist Attacks on Military Base of African Union Peacekeeping Forces in Somalia    Cabinet congratulates Sheikh Mohamed Bin Zayed on becoming UAE president    DGDA, Riyadh Third Health Cluster sign MoU to provide healthcare services in Diriyah    City Walk Receives Entertainment and Event Enthusiasts within Jeddah Season with Exciting Shows    Historic Jeddah Zone Attracts Visitors By Distinctive and Historical Shows    Jeddah Pier, the greatest amusement park on the sea, welcomes its visitors with delight and joy during the "Jeddah Season."    Riyadh to host first conference of IAEE in Middle East    EU ready to defend Finland and Sweden in event of Russian attack amid NATO bids    Heavy rains trigger floods in northeast India, killing 8    Guterres calls for 'swift formation' of inclusive Lebanese government    'Saudi women's participation in economic activities reach highest level with 35.6%'    UAE president, vice president congratulate King Salman on being discharged from hospital    Kay Mellor: Actress and Fat Friends creator dies aged 71    OIC Secretary General Receives Permanent Representative of Guinea-Bissau to OIC    Jeddah Jungle Welcomes Visitors with Thrilling Safari Experiences    Egypt to Host 2022 Annual Meetings of Islamic Development Bank Group in Sharm El Sheikh    Saudi Stock Exchange Main Index Ends Trading Lower at 12,689.87 Points    Ruler of Ajman Congratulates Custodian of Two Holy Mosques on Being Discharged from Hospital    KSrelief Distributes 3,121 Food Baskets to 18,726 Individuals in Hargeisa, Somaliland    Foreign direct investment in Saudi Arabia to jump 20 times by 2030: Al-Falih KSA develops business environment through massive reforms    Saudi delegation concludes partnerships with US capacity building companies    How cricket-crazy India scripted world badminton glory    Sri Lanka down to last day of petrol, warns new PM    Asian Shares Advance    Twitter boss hits back on Musk doubts over fake accounts    Abdulghani clinches first gold for Saudi Arabia in Gulf Games    Jazan Hosts West Asian Beach Soccer Championship    Gulf Health Council: Large sunglasses give better UVA protection    Former Australia cricketer Symonds dies aged 46 in car crash    Saudi citizen turns attention to sports after retirement    5 Arab women filmmakers receive Netflix grant    Over 250 Saudi Female and Male Players to Participate in Kuwait 3rd GCC Games on Friday    Saudi Deaf Athletics Team Leaves for Brazil    Bollywood actor's tweet reignited debate over Hindi as India's national language    SFDA Advises to Wash Dates Well Before Eating    SFDA Advises Against Mixing Surplus of Iftar and Suhoor with Different Foods or Surplus from Other Days    Ministry calls on imams to avoid long supplications in Tahajjud Prayer    Nothing wrong with a Muslim celebrating birthdays, says Saudi scholar    Ranbir Kapoor and Alia Bhatt: Bollywood wishes for star couple on wedding    SFDA Warns Against Microbes Accumulation on Coffee when Stored Incorrectly    SFDA: Over-roasting or roasting is not an indication of the level of food and may cause harm to human health    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques addresses citizens and all Muslims on the occasion of the Holy month of Ramadan    Pilgrims Perform Dhuhr and Asr Prayers at Arafat Holy Site    Council of Senior Scholars: Muslim Brothers' Group Don't Represent Method of Islam, rather only Follows its Partisan Objectives, Violating our Graceful Religion    Eid Al-Adha Prayer Performed at the Grand Holy Mosque    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Change does not always send a preview
Published in The Saudi Gazette on 02 - 09 - 2012


M.J. Akbar

The political scientist wonders whether a pendulum swing has not destabilized the democratic clock. The regional politician believes that a Third Front Prime Minister is an idea that cannot be quenched; national parties are convinced that it is merely an itch that can never be cured.
The search for a prime minister from outside the bipolar confines of Congress and BJP has been a consistent sub-plot of the Indian power play since the 1980s. What we call the “Third Front”, leaving the first two positions to Congress and BJP, is a consequence of the collapse of the Janata Party in 1981, and the inability of its non-BJP constituents to re-pool their sectarian resources into a credible presence in the Lok Sabha.
There are four distinct formations in Indian politics: the Congress, the Alternative Congress [defined primarily by its inability to accept family rule as a permanent factor within the party], the BJP and the Left. The Alternative Congress constitutes those who have been once in the Congress or the Socialist Party, and whose policy outlines are as fluid as those of the Congress, shifting from quasi-socialist to World Bank-reformist depending on need or environment. Its high point came in 1977, when, in the avatar of Janata Party, it led the Union government in Delhi.
It was entirely consistent that the Janata prime minister was a blue-blooded congressman, Morarji Desai, and its party president was a stalwart who had shifted from a socialist start to Indira Gandhi's Congress before he rebelled. The BJP, then called the Bharatiya Jana Sangh, also merged into Janata under public pressure in 1977, but never compromised its identity; a split and dispersal were inevitable after defeat in 1980. What was less understandable was the inability of the non-BJP elements to stick together within the Janata Party. They became victims of ego and hallucination to such an extent that repeated reminders by reality of their foolishness has not changed their habits. They clung on to zamindaris they could control autocratically, when a republic was theirs for the taking.
If the various entities that exist as sub-Congress parties went back to the parent, Congress would be able to restore single-party rule in the country.
But this will not happen as long as Congress is traumatized into believing that a Rahul Gandhi or a Priyanka Gandhi is a better option for PM than Sharad Pawar or a Nitish Kumar. The family worked as long as it was perceived as adding critical value to the vote garnered by regional satraps. But all over the country state-level leaders have replaced Congress as the principal inspiration for popular support, and in many places squeezed Congress to near-extinction. Why should Mamata Banerjee or Naveen Patnaik take orders from a “high command” when in fact the latter should be taking orders from them on matters pertaining to Bengal or Orissa? Politics is a practical business. Those who supply votes will demand authority.
BJP, as the principal force within the NDA, has understood that primacy does not mean supremacy. It is quite happy to play second fiddle in Bihar, leaving charge of the orchestra to Nitish Kumar. There are BJP leaders who resent this, arguing that this blocks the party's growth. But that is the price of electoral compulsions. If the BJP wants to come to power in a contemporary election it must deliberately lower the potential of its growth rate to levels that do not threaten its existing partners.
Temperamentally, Congress is less suited to compromise, either with foe or friend, but once again the desire to be in office today far outweighs the prospects of coming to power tomorrow. Since marriage is no longer considered compulsory for cohabitation in this liberated age, all alliances have only the mild glue of dalliance.
“Third Front” ambitions rise, therefore, when the Congress is in disarray. The logic that made Charan Singh, Deve Gowda and Inder Gujral prime minister was that Congress would accept anyone in order to keep the BJP out of power. Conversely, BJP's support for V.P. Singh as prime minister and Mufti Mohammad Sayeed as his home minister in 1989 was largely driven by the desire to keep Congress out of office. The 21st century has brought some changes. A thin coalition like the one headed by V. P. Singh or Deve Gowda will not be acceptable to the voter. When it falls, as it inevitably must, both the direct beneficiary of an artificial contrivance, and those who supported it, will be punished.
The next general elections will answer a vital question: will the Indian voter elect a Parliament that can only offer a weak PM? At a regional level a pattern has emerged. Change, when it comes, does so in a sweeping manner, demolishing the successor's option of an alibi. So far, a national pattern has not been so coherent. But change does not always send a preview. We must be prepared for surprise.

— M.J. Akbar is an eminent Indian journalist. Write to him at [email protected]


Clic here to read the story from its source.