A Palestinian farmer shows the damage to his land, that he said was caused by Israeli settlers' attack, to B'Tselem field researcher Iyad Hadad (left) in the West Bank village of Turmus Aya near Ramallah. B'Tselem is an Israeli NGO that has long been a bane of the government, tirelessly flagging human rights abuses by Israel's military in the Palestinian territories. — Reuters
Allyn Fisher-Ilan
On a backstreet in occupied Jerusalem sit the sparse offices of B'Tselem, an Israeli organization that has long been a bane of successive governments, tirelessly flagging military abuses in occupied Palestinian territory.
Set up by a group of academics, lawyers and politicians more than 25 years ago, the NGO — whose name means “in the image of” and is a synonym in Hebrew for human dignity — has at times portrayed itself as the conscience of the nation.
But legislation being proposed by Israel's new right-wing government threatens to severely limit the work of B'Tselem and scores of other Israeli NGOs that receive millions of dollars each year in donations from foreign governments and foundations.
While the legislation is in draft form, Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked of the ultra-nationalist Jewish Home party says she is determined to crack down on those who take foreign money and then criticize Israel, accusing the NGOs of “eroding the legitimacy of Israel to exist as a Jewish and democratic state”.
An earlier legislative draft she submitted before rising to cabinet rank after a March election proposed a tax of up to 45 percent on foreign donations unless otherwise approved by a committee of defense and foreign ministry officials.
From the point of view of advocacy groups, the proposals are a dangerous step that would put Israel in a category with the likes of Russia, Turkey and neighboring Egypt, which often struggle to accept internal criticism and have banned some NGOs.
“A super-enormous battle is being waged for the future of our society,” said Sarit Michaeli, B'Tselem's spokeswoman and a veteran activist who has spent years gathering evidence of alleged transgressions in the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
“What we have here are many years of intense efforts to discredit Israel's human rights community, primarily related to our work exposing human rights violations.”
‘Attack on sovereignty'
There are more than 30,000 NGOs registered in Israel, about half of them active. But the focus of frustration for Shaked and her supporters are around 70 whose work focuses on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and which receive funds either from the European Union as a whole, or individual governments, including Denmark, Sweden, Belgium and Norway.
NGO Monitor, an Israeli group set up to track the sector, and in its words make it more accountable, maintains a database of foreign funding to NGOs, using figures the organizations themselves are obliged to provide under Israeli law.
The figures show that just over 100 million shekels ($26 million) was donated to 24 of the most active NGOs during 2012-14, including Breaking the Silence, which collects anonymous testimony from Israeli soldiers; and Adalah, a legal rights organization focused on the Palestinians.
B'Tselem, one of the main recipients, says it was given 13.3 million shekels from US and European donors in that period, accounting for about two-thirds of its entire funding.
If Shaked's bill were to pass, Michaeli reckons B'Tselem could keep operating, albeit with a much reduced budget. Other, smaller NGOs might be forced to shut down.
But it is not so much the potential loss of funding that has NGO advocates alarmed, as the message that such legislation sends, even if it doesn't secure parliamentary backing.
In a country that has traditionally taken dissent on the chin, the move to clamp down reveals a new, thinner skin, one less accepting of opposing opinion, especially from those regarded by the government as having a left-wing agenda.
“There's a sense on the Israeli right that progressive or liberal viewpoints are a danger and that something has to be done about it,” said Matt Duss, the president of the Foundation for Middle East Peace in Washington, D.C.
“It has very negative connotations. It creates a hostile environment for those who express legitimate criticism and would put Israel in some very bad company.”
In the past, Israel has been able to hold itself up as a beacon of openness — the very existence of groups like Breaking the Silence and Peace Now, which monitors Israeli settlement building in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, was widely seen as a credit to Israel's pluralism.
One European ambassador expressed alarm that Israel could consider such legislation, describing it as the sort of move that would justify strong censure from the European Union.
It remains unclear how much backing Shaked will get if she does push ahead with the bill in the coming months. The indications are, however, that she is determined to do so.
NGO Monitor, which has raised questions about the accuracy of data gathered by groups like B'Tselem, says it doesn't support any bill that would punish the NGO community.
But its head, Gerald Steinberg, accuses B'Tselem and others of waging “a very dangerous form of warfare” against Israel and says legislation is needed to combat “the destructive European policy of funding political NGOs”.
Others see a different objective.
“Members of the government are out to settle scores,” said Duss, mentioning Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's election-day criticism of unspecified left-wing groups that he accused of helping to take Israeli-Arab voters to the polls. “It's part of a broader effort to limit the political space, to constrict the freedom of opposing views,” said Duss. — Reuters
