Claims of overcrowding, poor food, beatings MAKKAH – The National Society for Human Rights (NSHR) has found several shortcomings in basic services at an orphanage in Makkah – including alleged overcrowding, beatings and unhygienic food. Dr. Hussein Al-Shareef, the NSHR President, said a delegation visited the orphanage in Makkah on Saturday and discovered a number of violations. The delegation also tried to determine the truth of allegations by residents that they are being maltreated and beaten. Residents also complained that there is overcrowding at the facility, with up to 12 persons crowded into each room. They also complained about the alleged poor quality of food. The delegation did report a poor standard of cleanliness in the corridors, kitchens and toilets, which has allegedly resulted in the poor health of residents. Al-Shareef said he conducted the visit because of a recommendation made by the consultative board of the NSHR. The delegation consisted of Abdullah Khadhrawi, the society's executive director and members Muhammad Kalantin and Muhammad Al-Sahl. Al-Shareef said the visit enabled the society to detect “great shortcomings” in the performance of the orphanage, which is affiliated to the Ministry of Social Affairs. He said the preliminary report made after the visit showed that the delegation listened to each resident separately. This was to hear their complaints without any pressure from any party at the orphanage. He said one of the serious violations detected by the delegation was the maltreatment, which in some cases could be termed beatings. He said the delegation also sensed a general feeling of resentment and discontent especially regarding the quality of food. Residents alleged that they were served the same dishes everyday without any change. The delegation also noticed the poor standard of recreational and cultural programs. They said the building was 30 years and could not accommodate the current number of residents. The building was suited to accommodate 70 residents but was now home to more than 125 people. Al-Shareef said the final report will be submitted to Prince Khaled Al-Faisal, the Emir of Makkah, over the next few days, with a copy being sent to the relevant authorities for corrective action to be taken.
