King, Crown Prince congratulate German president on Unity Day    Sultan Humanitarian City wins platinum award at 2022 Patient Safety Congress in Dubai    Riyadh book fair symposium sheds light on Arab literature's influence across world    Saudi Arabia to host World Petroleum Congress in 2026    Jazan International Forum moots Saudi Coffee Day, Annual Coffee Award    Brazil election: Lula and Bolsonaro to face run-off    Iran protests: Students trapped amid clashes in Tehran    UK chancellor U-turns on plans to scrap tax rate    Record avian flu outbreak sees 48 million birds culled in UK and EU    Fans 'died in the arms' of players in Indonesia stadium crush    Fans of Sydney United 58 condemned for Nazi salutes during Australia Cup final    Saudi Ministry of Justice: 1.5 Million clients benefit from digital conveyance of title deeds    By International Consensus.. Saudi Arabia Retains its Seat in Council of ITU and Radio Regulations Board    Tadawul All Share Index Decreases by 0.79%, Equity Market Capitalization Reaches SAR 10,832.85 Billion at End of 1st Nine Months 2022    Asian Shares Mostly Lower    Weather Forecast for Monday    KSrelief Concludes the 11th, 12th Volunteer Program in Zaatari Camp for Syrian Refugees in Jordan    King Salman receives written message from Azerbaijan president    Recycling by 2035 will contribute to an annual income of SR120 billion    18 new benefit added to health insurance policy    Al-Manea: Selling gold in installments is not permissible    Saudi Stock Exchange Main Index Ends Trading Higher at 11,487 Points    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques Congratulates Chairman of the National Committee of Reconciliation and Development, Head of State, and President of the Republic Guinea on Independence Day    MAWANI, Tabadul Sign MoU to Develop New Saudi Ports Management Systems    Global Philosophers to Gather for Second Riyadh Philosophy Conference between 1-3 December    174 dead in Indonesian football stadium crush    Vehicle Overturn Kills 26, Injures 10 in India    At Least 127 People Killed, 180 Injured at Football Match in Indonesia    15 cups of Saudi coffee in a day are enough!    Riyadh hosts first Saudi Games on Oct. 27    19 women, 2 men qualify as Kingdom's first yogasana referees    Movies return to Kashmir with Hrithik Roshan-starrer    Body of famed US climber found on Mt Manaslu in Himalayas    Yoga introduced to Saudi universities    Islamic Minister Al-Sheikh: Juristic judgment catalyst to salvage Islamic Ummah    Culinary Arts Commission Registers 13 Foods on Slow Food List of Endangered Food    72% of Children Globally have been Victims of Cyber Threats    Saudi National Football Team Continues Preparations for Friendly Match against Ecuador    Saudi Futsal Team Beats San Marino, Wins Silver in Croatian International Championship    During 2nd Global AI Summit.. AI-powered Early Breast Cancer Detection Program Launched    Triple talaq: India Muslim women in limbo after instant divorce ruling    Film Commission Reviews Film Industry Prospects in Saudi Arabia at Venice International Film Festival    Saudi national volleyball team loses to Kyrgyzstan in Asian Challenge Cup final    Saudi national volleyball team beats Uzbekistan, qualifies for the final of the Asian Challenge Cup    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques Delivers Speech to Pilgrims, Citizens, Residents and Muslims around the World    Sheikh Al-Issa in Arafah's Sermon: Allaah Blessed You by Making It Easy for You to Carry out This Obligation. Thus, Ensure Following the Guidance of Your Prophet    Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques addresses citizens and all Muslims on the occasion of the Holy month of Ramadan    Pilgrims Perform Dhuhr and Asr Prayers at Arafat Holy Site    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



A Nuremberg trial for Guant?namo
By Guénaël Mettraux
Published in The Saudi Gazette on 21 - 08 - 2009

AT the end of World War II, the Allied powers found themselves in charge of thousands of captured enemies, many of whom had committed unspeakable crimes. Some among the victors thought that the prisoners should simply be shot. Others, including many in the American government, steadfastly insisted that these men should be subjected to criminal proceedings. Thus the Nuremberg trials were born, tribunals that meted out justice for some of the 20th century's worst atrocities while demonstrating the return of the rule of law on the European continent and the superiority of democratic values over Fascist lunacies.
The Guant?namo detainees pose a similar conundrum today. Trying these men stateside would necessarily require the compromise of long-cherished principles of American law. Yet continuing to hold them without the prospect of a fair trial or delivering them to undemocratic governments are alternatives not worthy of the Obama administration or of the United States.
America's own endeavors at Nuremberg offer a way out of this impasse: an international tribunal for detainees. Such a tribunal would allow the Obama administration to finally try these individuals and close down Guant?namo – and it would bring the nation back within the tradition of law and justice that it so forcefully defended six decades ago. We need not look as far back as Nuremberg. Recent international tribunals for Sierra Leone, Cambodia and Yugoslavia have provided fair trials in challenging political environments to men and women accused of the gravest of crimes. In The Hague right now, an international criminal tribunal is looking into the terrorist attacks that shook Lebanon in 2004 and 2005. This tribunal – created by the United Nations Security Council at the initiative of the United States, among others – provides a ready model of a court capable of dealing with the detainees.
Those now held in Guant?namo would be placed under international control and their trials held on neutral ground.
American and foreign judges and prosecutors with experience in international criminal cases would then be enlisted to provide the expertise required to hear these types of criminal cases.
As with the Special Tribunal for Lebanon, it would be paid for by a combination of American contributions and voluntary donations from other nations.
The support of the international community – particularly from Middle Eastern countries and those European nations that played a part in the detention or transfer of these men – would be imperative to providing legitimacy to the process and the guarantees of independence and impartiality necessary to its success.
Moreover, any convictions would need to bear the stigma of the entire world, not just that of a single nation. An international criminal tribunal would not answer all the legal questions surrounding the war on terrorism. But by putting its faith in the law, the Obama administration would send a potent message to both its supporters and its enemies.
By giving a fair trial to the Guant?namo detainees, the United States would reassert its core values and demonstrate the supremacy of those values over the evil that has been challenging them.
The chief prosecutor at Nuremberg, Robert H. Jackson, said: “We must never forget that the record on which we judge these defendants is the record on which history will judge us tomorrow.
To pass these defendants a poisoned chalice is to put it to our lips as well.” Let us hope that the wisdom of his prophecy has not been lost to those who will decide the fate of the Guant?namo detainees. – New York Times
Guénaël Mettraux, the author of “The Law of Command Responsibility,” represents defendants before international criminal tribunals. __


Clic here to read the story from its source.