Crown Prince decorates Commander of the Joint Forces    SWCC shares initiatives in realizing Saudi Green goals in London Forum    King Abdullah Port sponsors SMME reinforcing commitment to maritime sector    Jaishankar hails India-Russia ties ahead of Putin's visit    Saudi Export Development Authority Organizes Saudi Trade Mission to USA    Chairman of Saudi-French Parliamentary Friendship Committee Meets with Senior French Officials    Qatar Records 164 New Cases of COVID-19    Saudi Stock Exchange Main Index Ends Trading Lower at 11021 Points    LuLu group and EFAA group make kindness and support priority on World Disability Day.    Coalition forces shoot down two Houthi-fired drones    Saudi and GCC entrants set to dominate motorcycle and quad battles in Hail    10 days to go until Riyadh comes alive with MDLBEAST'S majestic shows    World Directs Attention to Final Round of FIA Cross Country Rally World Cup in Hail    King Abdullah Port Reinforces Commitment to Maritime Sector through Continued Sponsorship of 2021 SMME    Arab Justice Ministers Commence 37th Session    Pakistani education minister lauds Saudi e-learning success during the pandemic    Saudi Arabia, Pakistan sign agreement on labor recruitment    Saudi, Bahrain navies begin joint maritime exercise 'JISR-22'    Japan Reports 3rd Case of Omicron Variant in Traveller who Had Been in Italy    Germany Records 27,836 New COVID-19 Cases    Ministry of Islamic Affairs Stresses Necessity of Wearing Mask and Social Distancing in Mosques    Military truck rams into group of Myanmar protesters in Yangon    Nazaha arrests 250 government staff on charges of corruption    5-day Jeddah international motor show starts Today at 6 PM    Lewis Hamilton wins thrilling Saudi Arabian Grand Prix    Crown Prince attends inaugural Saudi Arabian Grand Prix    Deputy Governor of Hail: Hail International Rally is a practical translation of the wise leadership's support    Hail International Rally to Kick off Tomorrow    SAMI, Airbus to Form Joint Venture for Military Aviation MRO and Services    Death Toll Rises to 13 after Indonesia's Semeru Volcano Erupts    Saudi Aramco, French Companies Sign Agreements    Hamilton sets pace in free trials in Formula 1 STC Saudi Arabian Grand Prix    Red Sea Immersive to provide enthralling experience: Liz Rosenthal    Invest in Saudi Arabia Initiative Announces its Partnership with Formula 1 Saudi Grand Prix    Duchess of Sussex wins latest court battle with Mail on Sunday publisher    Trolls join UN campaign for healthier eating, sustainable living    BIENALSUR Exhibition Arrives in Jeddah at Historic Site of Qasr Khuzam    Saudi Hind Al-Showaier Elected Regional Director of World Federation of the Deaf    Saudi Film Commission launch its strategy to develop film and cinema sector    Bollywood superstar Salman Khan to dazzle Riyadh Season on Dec. 10    First Full International Marathon in Saudi Arabia to be Held in March 2022    Bollywood star's 'India got freedom in 2014' remark stirs controversy    23 Saudi women obtain favorable verdicts in 'adhl' lawsuits    Bride's fingerprint not required in revised e-marriage contract    Pilgrims Perform Dhuhr and Asr Prayers at Arafat Holy Site    Council of Senior Scholars: Muslim Brothers' Group Don't Represent Method of Islam, rather only Follows its Partisan Objectives, Violating our Graceful Religion    Eid Al-Adha Prayer Performed at the Grand Holy Mosque    Pilgrims Perform Dhuhr and Asr Prayers in Arafat Holy Site    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Fury in Brussels as Warsaw court rules Polish Constitution overrides EU law
Published in The Saudi Gazette on 08 - 10 - 2021

Poland's constitutional court has ruled that some European Union laws clash with Poland's Constitution.
In a decision that has caused anger in Brussels and is likely to further damage Poland's troubled relationship with the 27-member bloc, the Constitutional Tribunal in Warsaw judged that some provisions of the EU treaties and some EU court rulings go against Poland's highest law.
In a majority decision the judges said the country's EU membership did not give EU courts supreme legal authority and did not mean that Poland had shifted its sovereignty to the EU. They said no state authority in Poland would consent to an outside limitation of its powers.
Reacting to the ruling, the EU's justice commissioner stressed the primacy of EU law over national law. The main parties in the European Parliament took to Twitter to condemn the Polish verdict and urged the Commission to freeze payments for the country, which is the largest recipient of EU funds.
Brussels has been at loggerheads over the right-wing Polish government's attempts to exert more influence over the judiciary. It has called on the European Court of Justice to impose fines on Warsaw in a dispute over the rule of law.
In Thursday's ruling, the tribunal said that the constitution is the supreme law in Poland and every international agreement or treaty, being lower in rank, must respect that supreme law. The EU treaties are considered international agreements signed by nation-states.
The Polish tribunal took aim at two specific articles from the EU treaties: article 1, which establishes the existence of the European Union and the conferral of competences from member states, and article 19, which determines the powers of the EU's Court of Justice (ECJ), whose mission is to ensure the observance of EU law across the bloc.
Two of the 14 judges dissented from the ruling, which followed months of court proceedings. Poland's government, president and parliament argued that Poland's Constitution comes before EU law and that rulings by the ECJ sometimes conflict with Poland's legal order.
Poland's government insists that the justice system and the judiciary are the sole purview of EU member nations and not the EU, and has ignored a number of the EU court's rulings.
Opening the case in July, Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki asked for the review after the EU court ruled that the bloc's law takes precedence over Poland's law.
The Constitutional Tribunal itself is seen by the EU as illegitimate due to the political influence of Poland's governing party on the appointment of some of its judges. Many are government loyalists — including the court's president, Judge Julia Przylebska, who headed the panel in the current case.
It's unclear what kind of practical ramifications the Polish ruling will have in practice. The EU has never seen a member state's judicial system defy so openly the foundations of the bloc.
The reading of the Polish verdict coincided with a meeting of interior and justice ministers. Asked about the ruling, EU Justice Commissioner Didier Reynders said he needed more time to examine the court's decision but stressed the primacy of EU law over national law.
The Commissioner also underlined two additional principles: all decisions by the EU's Court of Justice are binding in all national courts and only the Luxembourg court has jurisdiction to determine if an act from another EU institution breaches EU law. Reynders added the executive intends to act as "guardian of the treaties" and use "all our tools at our disposal".
"Today's verdict in Poland cannot remain without consequences. The primacy of EU law must be undisputed. Violating it means challenging one of the founding principles of our Union," said David Sassoli, the President of the European Parliament.
"By declaring that the EU Treaties are not compatible with Polish law, the illegitimate Constitutional Tribunal in Poland has put the country on the path to Polexit," said a spokesperson from the centre-right European People's Party (EPP), the biggest in the hemicycle.
"EU Member States must not stand by idly when the rule of law continues to be dismantled by the Polish Government. Neither can the European Commission. Our money can't finance the governments which mock and negate our jointly-agreed rules."
"A black scenario in Poland is coming true! PiS-run Tribunal has disregarded the primacy of EU law, violating EU foundations. Polish judges adjudicating on the basis of EU law can face prosecution," said the left-wing S&D Group, calling for the opening of new infringement procedure.
"The PiS Government has created a crisis, but it is Polish citizens' rights that are at risk. Polish citizens are EU citizens and deserve the full protections and rights offered by EU law," wrote Malik Azmani, first vice-president of the liberal Renew Europe group.
"A Polexit from the EU legal order seems to become unavoidable. It effectively makes cooperation impossible," added his colleague Sophie in 't Veld.
"Today's ruling will be most painful for Polish citizens. They will have to bear the cost of frozen EU funds," tweeted Daniel Freund, a German member of the Greens. "This stunt was started by PiS. It is their mess."
Martin Schirdewan, co-chair of The Left group, lamented the Polish decision and predicted other autocratic governments will demand similar verdicts from their constitutional courts.
Amnesty International said it was "another dark day for justice in Poland".
The European Conservatives & Reformists (ECR) group, to which PiS belongs, came out in defence of the Polish constitutional court.
"Those calling for Polexit should be reminded that our Union was created by member states to serve them – not the other way around," the group wrote in response.
"The EU has no legal right to interfere in how judges are appointed in a democratic member state."
The EU is, at its core, an entity based on principles of law. Member states agree to confer competences to the union which, in turn, drafts and passes laws that are equally applicable across the bloc. These laws, together with multiple programs, projects and economic plans, are meant to advance the common interests of all member states. — Euronews


Clic here to read the story from its source.